Case comment

During the proceedings, the counsel of the NGO had suggested that instead of forming a TV Channel or live streaming, the proceedings should be video recorded and hosted on the official website of the apex Court. Section 5 of U.

drafting of law reports

The best way to learn how to do a case commentary is to read a few. The purpose of a case comment is to give a writer the opportunity to assess not only how a specific case was disposed of in court, but also 1 to survey the development of that area of the law represented by the selected case and 2 socio-political consequences of the decision.

This process is called as the 'delegated legislation'.

Legal commentary example

At the same time the judgment must be analyzed and its socio-political impacts discussed. Because case comments often deal with controversies within the law, students should be prepared to take a strong position when analyzing a case. Contact Us Search Legislature must perform its essential functions of law-making which consists in the determination or choice of the legislative policy and of formally enacting that policy into binding rule of conduct. It is useful to note any dissenting opinions if written because these opinions can give you some indication of how controversial the majority decision is, and may persuade you of a line of criticism of the majority. Issues: 1 Whether possession of weapons and explosive substances are for the preparation of a terrorist act or not? Since this is a prohibitory notification, therefore, it is necessary to be published by notifying about the 'possession of certain kinds of arms in the notified area that it is prohibited'. Legislature has enacted a Union Law i. The former is an invaluable guide to legal research because it contains a review of the Constitutional law decisions of the previous Supreme Court term.

This means that students should feel free to criticize court judgements if those judgements seem inappropriate though criticisms should be grounded in argument. Indira Jaising, in her PIL, had sought video-recording of proceedings on matters of national importance.

How to write a case note

It is useful to note any dissenting opinions if written because these opinions can give you some indication of how controversial the majority decision is, and may persuade you of a line of criticism of the majority. But, however, Indira Jaising stressed the need to include safeguards to prohibit unlawful reproduction of broadcasts. Contact Us Search Legislature must perform its essential functions of law-making which consists in the determination or choice of the legislative policy and of formally enacting that policy into binding rule of conduct. This means that students should feel free to criticize court judgements if those judgements seem inappropriate though criticisms should be grounded in argument. The Bench has said that appropriate Rules in that regard will be framed soon under Article of the Constitution of India. Because case comments often deal with controversies within the law, students should be prepared to take a strong position when analyzing a case. Miscellaneous Hints: a. Conditional legislation is of different types: i power to bring an Act into operation; ii power to extend the application of any Act in force in one territory to another territory; and to restrict and make modifications in the original legislation to suit the exigencies of the territory under its control; iii power to extend the life of an act; and iv power to extend or to exempt from the operation of an Act certain categories of subjects or territories. Two general texts on Canadian constitutional law that are helpful in pointing out how courts have decided broad areas of the law are: Peter W. This means explaining what was decided, by whom e.

Case commentaries can be found in legal journals like the Supreme Court Law Review or Osgoode Hall Law Journal one of many university law journals—this one is accessible online through the York University library system. You should be prepared to go beyond this synopsis when describing the main issues.

The executive has to decide whether the necessary conditions required for the law to be in operation have been satisfied or not and if they have been so, it should issue a notification bringing the law into operation.

Case comment template

For cases have not only a legal but a social and political significance. Mandal Revenue Officer[3], held that the requirement of publication in the Gazette of an exemption given under Section 11 1 of the AP Non-Agricultural Lands Assessment Act , was mandatory and not directory. During his period of internship he has worked on various matters of Constitutional importance which were heard in the Supreme Court. Section 5 of U. This means explaining what was decided, by whom e. Alberta, [] A case analysis is an extended commentary on a particular court case. At the same time the judgment must be analyzed and its socio-political impacts discussed.

A case comment should therefore be regarded as a type of interpretative essay which focuses on a particular case, but which is not limited to a simple exposition of its details.

Rated 7/10 based on 20 review
Download
Case Comment on SK. Shukla V State of Uttar Pradesh