Limitations of transformational leadership
The outcome he eventually achieved, however, led his people away from moral betterment.
Thus, transformational leadership can often fizzle when the early excitement wanes, especially if the company begins to hit pitfalls or sees similar declines in sales or profits. Although this can be effective in achieving goals easily with less or no objections, this can have a negative impact if the leader is immoral or is self-serving.
Barriers to transformational leadership
They feel an energy drain when they are forced into a position where they must make difficult decisions. Another example is emergencies that require quick decisions. Knowing what they are will be helpful to organizations in determining if this is the leadership style they need in achieving their goals. Leaders Are Confused Although employees have stated a preference for a transformational leadership style, one study found that often employers only thought they were providing it. Followers get caught up in this passion, believing the leader has the ability to make a big difference in their lives. Each positive opportunity offers a negative outcome potential as well. A study of transformational leaders in India by V. It is a leadership style which may ignore certain protocols. If the leader is a risk-taker who will make decisions that are not well thought and can result to something negative, chances are, the subordinates will be the ones to be put in line. Human resources systems to hire and retain top talent and train and develop employees are necessary for sustained growth and development. These can be a barrier or obstruction for these leaders to research or look deeper into the situation. Transformational leaders can actually alter the strengths of their followers through their emphasis on communication and motivation. They make the changes themselves, which encourages others to make the changes as well.
Some individuals might find additional collaborative and leadership roles and responsibilities too taxing. They use this energy to show people how to achieve goals or accomplish tasks. Their high level of involvement in achieving collective goals and objectives might leave them feeling overworked or even exploited.
Positive and negative effects of transformational leadership
When used in decisive or heroic ways, followers become fully motivated to work toward what they feel is a righteous cause. That leads to higher levels of productivity, higher levels of team morale, and lower levels of follower turnover. There must be a certain morality in place to pursue a shared vision for everyone if this leadership style is to succeed. Transformational leaders are excellent communicators. Kroeck, and N. Transformational leaders often focus on individual needs. It is a leadership style which focuses heavily on ethics. Print Transformational leadership is both a theory and a style of leadership in which a leader employs more specific approaches or mechanisms to build and maintain relationships, increase the motivation and morale, and improve the performance of the followers. Transformational leaders use their charismatic approach to serve as a role model for their followers and their organization. Can Place High Amounts of Pressure on the Followers One of the advantages of transactional leadership, as well as an authoritarian style of leadership, is that they place the pressure and accountability on the leader. If the leader has bad plans, followers might be deceived and be lured to go with whatever decisions the leader makes. It quickly changes low-morale situations.
However, transformational leaders specialize in formulating forward-looking visions and communicating them to employees.
Challenges in Details Although transformational leadership model has benefits like having a vision and long-term plans, critics say that these can leave details out of the picture which can have a negative impact on the organization. Some struggle, though, to carry on the momentum for months or years.
Limitations of transformational leadership
Through this process, they can do more than stimulate others toward success through their role-modeling. The transformational leader does not want to use their position to control others. Creating a positive energy and increasing morale are among the first goals of transformational leadership. They treat each follower as an individual, with their own unique needs and capabilities. Discipline Transforming a company has a naturally short-term orientation. Transformational leadership works best with employees who prefer to be part of the process and who also work well together. DOI: Additionally, leaders at some point must make hard decisions and come up with structured budgets to maintain cost controls. Although this can lead to leadership trainings and enhancement of knowledge within the organization, these opportunities are only given to selected individuals.
Fosters Organizational Change By Influencing Positive Behavior Another strength of transformational leadership is that it helps an organization go through change because it positively influences the behavior of employees.
When you see someone having a good time, then you want to share in that experience.
They do an excellent job of encouraging their followers to work together to achieve strategic goals.
based on 31 review